You have scrolled the listing sites, joined the Facebook groups and sent twenty messages. Nobody answers, or the apartment is gone before you can visit. This is not about you, and it is not about your French. For a newcomer, renting in Paris is genuinely difficult, and the main reason is legal.
My position is this. When the law regulates a market, it creates winners and losers. In France, the law of 6 July 1989 (loi n° 89-462) protects the tenant already in place so strongly that the landlord cannot get rid of him quickly, even if he stops paying. The winner is the sitting tenant. The loser is the person who wants to get in. Since the landlord cannot protect himself afterwards, he protects himself before: he rents only to someone he can pursue in France. A tenant who lives abroad cannot be pursued. That is reason number 1, and the other explanations you will read are secondary.
This article sets out the mechanism, explains why the fight against Airbnb has made things worse, compares Paris with Montréal, where I signed a lease in a single meeting, and ends with what you can do. It is general information, not advice on your own file.
Why is it so hard to rent an apartment in Paris?
Because the landlord cannot remove a tenant who stops paying quickly, and cannot protect himself with a large deposit or advance rent. He therefore rents to the person he can sue, seize and collect from in France. An applicant who lives abroad, with income and a guarantor abroad, cannot offer that. Competition, paperwork and insurers’ criteria come on top.
How does French law create winners and losers?
The loi n° 89-462 of 6 July 1989 governs residential leases. Three features matter here.
- The lease is long. When the landlord is an individual, the lease runs for three years (article 10).
- The landlord cannot end it freely. He can give notice only for the reasons the law lists, such as selling or taking the apartment back for himself (article 15; see the grounds for giving notice, in French).
- Payment guarantees are capped. The deposit cannot exceed one month of rent for an unfurnished apartment (article 22) and two months for a furnished one (article 25-6; see how a deposit is recovered or withheld, in French). A landlord cannot impose rent in advance either: the tenant can always ask to pay monthly (article 7, to which article 22 refers), and if the rent is payable more than two months in advance, no deposit can be taken at all.
The winner is the tenant who is already inside. The loser is the applicant outside. This is a general effect of regulated markets, and it is not specific to France, but it is particularly strong here.
How long does it take to remove a tenant who does not pay?
The procedure of article 24 has several mandatory stages:
- A commissaire de justice serves a payment demand. The tenant has six weeks to pay (article 24, I).
- If he does not pay, the landlord sues for termination of the lease, and the prefect must be notified at least six weeks before the hearing (article 24, III).
- The judge may grant payment delays of up to three years, provided the tenant can pay his debt and has resumed paying the current rent before the hearing (article 24, V).
- Once the court order is served, enforcement follows, and between 1 November and 31 March evictions are in principle suspended (article L412-6 of the Code des procédures civiles d’exécution).
My experience as a practitioner. I work on evictions. A landlord who rents to the wrong person (see how landlords try to avoid unpaid rent, in French) should plan for two to three years between the first unpaid rent and the day the apartment is actually returned. For you, as a tenant, the consequence is the other side of the same coin: once you hold the keys, you are in for a long time. The landlord knows it before he hands them over.
Why does this make a foreign applicant almost impossible?
The landlord’s reasoning is simple. If the tenant stops paying, he will have to wait two or three years, so he must be sure that the tenant can pay two or three years of rent. He cannot ask for more than one or two months of deposit, so the guarantee has to be the person. Two types of person pass.
A tenant who has resources of his own, and who lives in France. The landlord can have him ordered to pay by a French court, instruct a French commissaire de justice and seize his French bank accounts.
A tenant who lives abroad cannot be treated this way. A French judgment may be obtained against him, but collecting it is another matter: a commissaire de justice acts in France. This is my practitioner’s view of enforcement, and I give it as my position and not as a rule of law. It applies to the guarantor as well. Article 22-1 forbids a landlord to refuse a guarantor because he is not French or does not live in metropolitan France, and the Défenseur des droits makes the same point about guarantors who live abroad. The landlord must accept the guarantor in law. In practice he discounts him, for the same reason. Where the line runs between a lawful economic criterion and an unlawful discrimination is the subject of my article on refusals of foreign applicants.
My position. If you do not live in France, renting an apartment there is almost impossible. Everything else is secondary.
What do foreigners do instead?
A grey market has grown for them, close to the Airbnb market and to short-term furnished rentals: agencies on the internet, much higher prices, and a quality of service that is not better, because you remain a tenant under French rules and French service. If the shower stops working overnight, or the walls are damp, you are largely left to yourself. This is my observation, not a statistic. A reading of about 135 recent posts in two public Facebook housing groups for Paris on 13 November 2026 points the same way: most offers were furnished sublets or stays priced by the night, and the lettings for a year asked for a guarantor or Visale. It is an illustration, not a survey. On what is legal in a sublet, see my article on subletting in Paris.
One legal route exists for some profiles: the bail mobilité, a furnished lease of one to ten months with no deposit (article 25-17 of the 1989 law). It is reserved for people in training, higher education, an apprenticeship, an internship, a civic service engagement, a professional transfer or a temporary assignment. I compare it with the ordinary furnished and unfurnished leases in my article on lease types.
Why has the fight against Airbnb made it worse?
Rental to a clientele with no domicile there is exactly what French regulation has been fighting. The loi n° 2024-1039 of 19 November 2024, known as the loi Le Meur, raised the maximum civil fine for an irregular tourist furnished rental to 100 000 euros per premises. Paris applies a prior authorization regime to secondary residences, a ceiling on the number of days for a principal residence, and its local urban plan bans new tourist furnished rentals in a large part of the city. I have set out these rules in my article on the loi Le Meur of 19 November 2024 and short-term rentals (in French).
Exact law first: renting short term to a transient clientele is not forbidden, it is regulated, with authorization, ceilings and heavy penalties. My position: the combined effect is that a landlord is pushed away from any tenant who is not tied to a French domicile. If a foreigner cannot find an apartment in France, it is because the regulation has done everything to discourage renting to him, whether through a long lease or through a short one.
Why was it so quick in Montréal?
My experience. In Montréal I signed a lease with a landlord who had never met me. We agreed on a time, I came, I signed, and that was all. I have often asked myself why this was impossible in Paris.
The Québec texts I have read support the same explanation, as far as I can tell:
- Article 1904 of the Code civil du Québec forbids the landlord to ask for a deposit or any sum beyond the first rent. Québec and France both limit the landlord’s cash protection, so the entrance is not what separates the two systems.
- Under article 1971, the landlord can ask for the lease to be terminated when the tenant is more than three weeks late. The exit door is much faster than in Paris.
- A Québec landlord may check your payment history with a credit check, but only with your consent, and may contact your former landlords. He cannot demand your salary or payslips (Éducaloi).
- The lease uses a mandatory form from the Tribunal administratif du logement (TAL), and the landlord must give the new tenant notice of the last rent paid (article 1896).
Québec protects its tenants too, so the difference is not that one system protects and the other does not. The difference is how long a mistake lasts. In Montréal a landlord who rents to the wrong person can leave within weeks. In Paris he is stuck for years. A landlord who risks a few weeks can rent to a stranger. A landlord who risks years cannot.
The market also played a part. According to CMHC (SCHL), the Montréal vacancy rate rose from 2.1 percent in 2024 to 2.9 percent in 2025 (Noovo), and a CMHC specialist cited by the press recalls that it ran between 3 and 4 percent from 2006 to 2016 (Noovo). My experience belongs to a looser period.
What are the other explanations, and how do they rank?
I rank them below the first one. They deserve a fair hearing, because the evidence is not complete.
- Competition. According to Manda, a Paris listing drew about 41 candidates in the first half of 2026, against 13 nationally, and the median time to let was 15 days. With so many applicants, the landlord can keep only the safest. This is the same selection, made easier by the number of candidates.
- The insurer. Many landlords insure against unpaid rent. The insurer applies its own criteria, often stricter than the law, such as an income of about three times the rent. Under article 22-1, a landlord who has taken out this insurance cannot also demand a guarantor, unless the tenant is a student or an apprentice (written answer of the Government to a parliamentary question on article 22-1). A landlord who would gladly rent to you can therefore decline because his insurer would not cover your profile.
- The document file. The decree n° 2015-1437 of 5 November 2015 gives an exhaustive list of the documents a landlord may request. The decree requires documents written or translated into French, with amounts converted into euros (article 1 of the decree), so a foreign file with foreign payslips is hard to read in a pile of twenty files. The exact lists are in my article on what a landlord can ask you before signing.
- Scarce supply. The rent cap is often blamed. The evaluation published by the Apur in April 2026 found no lasting and significant effect of the cap on the Paris rental supply between 2018 and 2025, while the Government says the effect could not be measured precisely. Scarcity explains the competition, not necessarily through the cap.
What would tell my explanation apart from these? If the main problem were paperwork or scarcity, a well documented foreign file would pass as easily as a French one. If the main problem is recovery, anything that removes the enforcement problem should open doors: a solvent guarantor who lives in France, or a guarantee paid by a French body such as Visale. Landlords’ behaviour with those two instruments is the test. It is not a clean one: landlords do not agree on which guarantee they accept, competition remains, and online testimonies include applicants who held a Visale guarantee and still received almost no answer. Those testimonies are anecdotes, not statistics. They show that a guarantee opens the door to being examined, not to being chosen.
What can a newcomer do in practice?
- Find a guarantor who lives in France. It answers the landlord’s real question. Read the difference between a simple surety and an autonomous guarantee in my article on guarantees (in French) before you sign one.
- Ask about Visale. Action Logement offers this free guarantee to eligible tenants, and it is the instrument that removes the enforcement problem. Not every landlord accepts it, and the conditions are strict. Check your eligibility on the official site before you rely on it. The options without a French guarantor are compared in my article on renting without one.
- Consider a bail mobilité or a furnished apartment if your profile fits, and compare the price with the unfurnished market. A sublet or an « attestation d’hébergement » is not a lease: read what is legal in a sublet first.
- Build the strongest file the list allows. DossierFacile, the State’s free service, helps assemble and share a file in a standard form. Do not hand over more than the decree allows.
- Never pay before you have signed. The law forbids a landlord or an agency to claim any sum before the lease is signed, including a reservation fee (justice.fr). Scams on listing sites and Facebook groups typically start with exactly this request: see how to spot a rental scam and what to do if you were scammed.
Is the rent cap going to change this?
Rent control in Paris dates from the law ELAN n° 2018-1021 of 23 November 2018 and has applied since 1 July 2019. The experiment ends on 24 November 2026. On 21 October 2026 the Senate voted by 325 votes to 17 to extend it to 2028. As of 13 November 2026, the National Assembly still has to adopt the text unchanged before 24 November, and the vote is expected on 19 November. My explanation does not depend on this vote: with or without a cap, the lease term, the deposit limits and the eviction procedure remain.
If you already live in a Paris apartment and think you pay too much, see my article on Paris rent control and how to get your money back. On how a landlord evicts, see my article on evicting a tenant (in French).
When should you talk to a lawyer?
A lawyer cannot find you an apartment, and a general article cannot say whether a given clause or a given refusal is lawful in your case. I can help in the cases where the law does give you rights: a lease you are about to sign, a guarantor who is being asked too much, a document request that goes beyond the decree, a deposit that is not returned, or a rent above the cap. English-speaking clients can find the practical details on my page for English-speaking clients in Paris.
By Valentin Simonnet, Avocat au Barreau de Paris (Paris Bar), simonnetavocat.fr



