Can a Landlord Refuse You Because You Are a Foreigner in France?

You applied, the file was complete, and the landlord said no. Or nobody replied at all. You wonder whether it was your passport, your accent or your name. French law does forbid some refusals. But the refusal that happens most often is not the one the law forbids most clearly.

My position is this. A landlord who cannot easily remove a tenant who stops paying wants a tenant he can pursue in France: with a French guarantor, French income and a French bank account. That is an economic criterion, and it hits foreigners much harder than French applicants. The law punishes discrimination by origin. It does not clearly punish a criterion that is neutral on its face but that foreigners rarely meet. That gap is where most refusals sit.

This article draws the line between the two, explains who has to prove what, and sets out how to complain. It is general information, not advice on your own file. For the wider mechanism, see my article on why renting in Paris is so hard for newcomers.

Can a landlord in France refuse you because you are a foreigner?

No, a landlord may not refuse you because of your origin or another ground listed in article 225-1 of the Code pénal. Article 1 of the loi n° 89-462 of 6 July 1989 forbids it, and article 225-2 punishes it with three years in prison and a 45,000 euro fine. A refusal because you lack a guarantor or income pursuable in France is an economic reason, lawful in principle unless it hides a discriminatory one.

What exactly does French law forbid?

Article 1 of the loi n° 89-462 of 6 July 1989 says that nobody can be refused a rental « pour un motif discriminatoire défini à l’article 225-1 du code pénal ». The list of article 225-1 includes origin, place of residence and a particular economic vulnerability. It also covers the ability to speak a language other than French. And it covers belonging or not belonging, truly or supposedly, to an ethnic group, a Nation, a so-called race or a religion.

A common mistake is to say that « nationality » is a listed ground. The word does not appear in the current text of article 225-1. The Défenseur des droits (the independent authority that handles discrimination complaints) nevertheless reads refusals based on nationality as covered, in decision n° 2018-020 of 9 March 2018 and decision n° 2018-212 of 26 September 2018. That is the authority’s analysis, not a ruling by a court.

Article 225-2 of the Code pénal punishes the refusal to supply a good or a service. It also punishes making it conditional on a prohibited criterion. The penalty is three years in prison and a 45,000 euro fine. The penalty rises to five years and 75,000 euros when the refusal takes place in a place open to the public. Article 225-3 lists exceptions, and none of them covers an ordinary refusal of a tenant.

The law also covers indirect discrimination. Article 1 of the loi n° 2008-496 of 27 May 2008 defines it as a rule or practice that looks neutral but creates a particular disadvantage for people who share one of the listed grounds. It escapes the ban only if it is « objectivement justifié par un but légitime » and the means are necessary and appropriate. Article 2, 3° of the same law applies the ban to access to goods and services. That legitimate-aim defence is not available for differences of treatment based on origin, surname or a supposed ethnic group or race. A landlord can therefore plead a recovery concern against a criterion tied to residence, but not against one tied to origin.

Who has to prove what?

The rule favours the applicant, up to a point. Under article 1 of the 1989 law, the person refused presents facts suggesting direct or indirect discrimination. The landlord then has to prove that his decision is justified, and the judge may order any investigative measure he considers useful. Article 4 of the loi n° 2008-496 states that this mechanism does not apply before criminal courts, where the offence must be proved under ordinary criminal rules.

You still need facts. The Défenseur des droits quotes the Conseil constitutionnel (decision n° 2001-455 DC of 12 January 2002): the applicant must establish « éléments de fait précis et concordants ». A bare feeling is not enough. An advertisement, an email, a recorded call or a comparison with another applicant is.

What is clearly illegal?

Three examples show where the line sits.

  1. Extra conditions for foreigners. The Défenseur des droits considers that demanding a residence permit from a foreign applicant who already proves his identity with a passport or a foreign identity card creates conditions that apply to foreigners only. In decision n° 2018-020, it calls this « une discrimination prohibée fondée sur la nationalité ». It relies on the analysis of the ANIL (the national housing information agency) and on a statement of the housing minister in February 2017. The minister confirmed that the 2015 decree on the documents a landlord may ask for does not allow extra documents for foreigners.
  2. A refusal after an expired residence permit. In decision n° 2018-212, an engineer with a permanent contract, whose permit had expired but who held a renewal receipt, was refused by an agency. Their income was 3.7 times the rent. The agency’s new director wrote that the applicants had probably been victims of discrimination. The Défenseur des droits recommended an amicable settlement and compensation. This was a recommendation, not a judgment.
  3. A discriminatory instruction applied by an intermediary. The Cour d’appel d’Amiens (chambre correctionnelle, 11 March 2009, n° 08/01120) upheld the conviction of a rental agency and its manager for making rentals conditional on a racial criterion. The agency’s staff used a code on property files to reflect owners’ preferences. The agency was fined 10,000 euros, suspended, and the manager was exempted from penalty. The court called the association’s testing « peu probant »; the conviction rested on the code and on the employees’ statements. The facts date from 2000 to 2003.

If you want to read more on what a landlord may and may not ask in your file, see my article on what a landlord can ask before signing.

What if the landlord refuses because you have no guarantor or income in France?

This is the case I see as the real battleground, and the law is less clear. Three situations must be kept apart.

  • The same criterion for everyone. The landlord rejects any applicant who has no guarantor or income he can pursue in France, French or not. This is an economic criterion.
  • The criterion used as a screen. The landlord applies it to some applicants and not to others, or applies it only after he learns where you come from. That is a discrimination case, and the facts are the evidence.
  • A refusal of the guarantor himself. Article 22-1 of the 1989 law says that a landlord who requires a guarantor « ne peut refuser la caution » because the guarantor is not French or does not live in metropolitan France.

On the third situation, two written answers of the Government to parliamentary questions point the same way. In question n° 40908 (JO of 22 July 2014, p. 6249), the Ministry treated the refusal of a tenant’s file because the guarantor lives abroad as falling under the discrimination ban, subject to the judge’s control. In question n° 18896 (JO of 18 June 2019, p. 5608), it recalled article 22-1 and pointed to Visale, the free public guarantee. A ministerial answer does not bind a judge.

The Défenseur des droits goes further. Its 2025 guide Louer sans discriminer says a landlord may not refuse the guarantor because of foreign nationality or residence outside metropolitan France. It cites decision n° 2024-095 of 3 July 2024, which held that requiring a guarantor who is French or lives in France is illegal and a discrimination by association. It also cites an amicable settlement of 24 August 2023 (RA-2023-049) for a refusal based on a guarantor living abroad. I read these two references in the guide, not the full texts. They are the authority’s analysis, not court rulings.

One more rule from the same article 22-1 helps in practice. A landlord who has taken out rent insurance or another guarantee cannot also demand a guarantor, on pain of nullity. The exception is a flat let to a student or an apprentice. If an agency asks for both a guarantor and its own insurance, that is worth raising.

What did a court say about a guarantor who lives abroad?

I found one recent judgment on the point. The juge des contentieux de la protection of the Tribunal judiciaire de Chambéry (3 September 2026, RG n° 24/00392) decided a dispute over a shared flat. A departing co-tenant said the landlord had refused his replacement for reasons linked to origin. The landlord’s heirs answered that the replacement’s guarantor was not domiciled in France, which would make enforcement more difficult.

The court held that discrimination was not established: no document from the landlord mentioned origin, and the only reason on record was the guarantor’s domicile. It added that only the refused candidate could sue for damages. The passage does not discuss article 22-1. This is a first-instance judgment, tied to its facts.

Hypotheses: is refusing a foreign-based guarantor lawful?

The decisions I found do not settle it. Three readings compete, and what would distinguish them is different for each.

  • It is forbidden by article 22-1. This is the reading of the Ministry’s answers and of the text, which refers to guarantors who do not live in metropolitan France. A judgment applying article 22-1 to a refusal of the file, and not only to a refused guarantor, would confirm it. I did not find one.
  • It is a lawful recovery criterion. This is the outcome in the Chambéry judgment, which does not mention article 22-1 on this point; the debate there may simply not have raised it. A decision reading article 22-1 as limited to the guarantee itself, and not to the file, would confirm this reading.
  • It is a potential indirect discrimination. A criterion that looks neutral, such as « guarantor domiciled in France », disadvantages foreigners. The landlord would then have to show a legitimate aim and necessary means. Facts would tip the balance: whether he accepted a French-resident guarantor of foreign nationality, whether he refused a guarantor who lives in another European country, and whether he turned down an alternative such as Visale.

Note also that the definition of article 1 of the loi n° 2008-496 lists a person’s « domiciliation bancaire » among the grounds, while article 225-1 of the Code pénal does not. Whether that difference lets a civil claim go further than the criminal text is a question I found no decision on.

My experience as a practitioner. I work on evictions. A landlord who rents to the wrong person should plan for two to three years before he gets his apartment back (see how landlords try to avoid unpaid rent, in French). That is why he asks for a tenant he can pursue in France, and why the Chambéry heirs said what they said. On how an eviction works, see my article on evicting a tenant (in French). The landlord does not need to dislike foreigners to refuse one.

What I observe in Facebook groups. In the groups I read on 13 November 2026, advertisements for year-long rentals often say « Guarantor or Visale insurance required ». I did not find an account of a refusal attributed to nationality. This is an observation of advertisements, not a study.

How do you spot the difference in practice?

Ask yourself these questions, from the strongest sign of discrimination to the weakest.

  1. Was anything demanded from you that is not demanded from French applicants? A residence permit, when your passport already proves your identity, is the example the Défenseur des droits has examined. This is the strongest sign.
  2. Was the refusal tied to your name, language or country, in writing or on a recording? A message, an advertisement or a call that mentions origin is direct evidence.
  3. Was a comparable file from a French applicant accepted? You rarely see this, but the Défenseur des droits can ask the agency for the files of the candidates it retained, as it did in decision n° 2018-020.
  4. Was the reason that no one could pursue you in France? Then it looks like the economic criterion, and your best answer is to remove the problem. A guarantor in France is one way; read the difference between a simple surety and an autonomous guarantee (in French) before you sign one. See also my article on renting in Paris without a French guarantor.

Keep the advertisement, the exchange of messages, the dates and the names. The Défenseur des droits asks applicants to keep exactly this kind of evidence.

What is testing, and does it work?

Testing means sending two comparable applications that differ only in the protected characteristic. Article 225-3-1 of the Code pénal says that discrimination offences exist even when committed against someone who applied to show the discriminatory behaviour, as long as the behaviour is proved.

Testing is valid evidence, but it is not magic. In the Amiens case above, the court found the association’s testing weak. The convictions rested on documents and witness statements. The Cour de cassation (chambre criminelle) has also ruled on who can sue. When the offence targets named individuals, an anti-racism association needs their consent to join the case (25 November 2008, n° 07-88.006; 28 September 2010, n° 09-88.269, a testing case about rental offers).

How do you complain?

You can go to the Défenseur des droits, to the police or prosecutor, or to a civil court.

  • The Défenseur des droits. Article 5, 3° of the loi organique n° 2011-333 of 29 March 2011 lets any person who believes he was discriminated against refer the matter to it, including when the author is a private person. Article 6 says the referral is free. For discrimination, no prior step with the person complained about is required, since article 6 exempts the competences of article 4, 2° to 5°. You can call 3928 or use the chat on antidiscriminations.fr. The Défenseur des droits can mediate, propose a settlement and make recommendations, as in decision n° 2018-212.
  • Language. It may be possible to write in English, but the pages I read do not say so; the safest course would be to ask when you call 3928, or to write in French.
  • Time limits. Article 6 states that a referral to the Défenseur des droits does not suspend limitation periods. The criminal action for a délit lapses after six years (article 8 of the Code de procédure pénale). For a civil claim for damages, the general rule is five years (article 2224 of the Code civil). Do not wait.
  • Compensation. A civil action, or a civil party claim in a criminal case, is how you obtain damages. The Défenseur des droits cannot award them, but it can recommend a settlement.

Is it worth going further?

It depends on the facts. If you have written evidence that your origin or nationality was the reason, a complaint to the Défenseur des droits is free and may lead to a settlement. My position: if the reason was that you had no guarantor or income in France, expect the landlord to answer that this is an economic criterion. A complaint is then a weaker bet, and your time may be better used to remove the objection, for instance with a furnished lease or the mobility lease if your profile fits. Be wary of any agent who asks for money or documents before a visit: see my article on rental scams in Paris.

When should you talk to a lawyer?

A general article cannot tell you whether your own refusal was discriminatory. The answer depends on the messages, the dates and what was asked of other applicants. A lawyer can read the file, tell you which route is realistic, and speak to the landlord or the agency. If you are in a wider dispute with a landlord, see also my article on conflicts with a landlord (in French). If you want to discuss a refusal, a guarantor who is being rejected, or a document request that goes beyond the decree, see my page for English-speaking clients in Paris.

By Valentin Simonnet, Avocat au Barreau de Paris (Paris Bar), simonnetavocat.fr

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *